Christmas cookie recipes and tips.

Come December, I find myself baking ridiculous quantities of cookies. I’m not sure why; there are just two of us here at home, and I don’t usually go to cookie-swap parties [unless anyone wants to plan one and invite me?]. It’s like the swallows returning to Capistrano or the monarchs migrating to Mexico: I’m seasonally, instinctively, inexplicably compelled to bake.

Time is of the essence, and I’ve begun my baking preparation, searching for new and old favorite Christmas cookie recipes to make and assembling a stockpile of ingredients. In the seasonal spirit, I’ll be sharing some of my favorite Christmas cookie recipes here throughout December: a few old-fashioned favorites from Clara Shenefelt’s collection (read about The Clara Project and see vintage recipes), a couple of cookie recipes I’ve posted here in past years and want to spotlight again and a few recipes I’ve never made before.

Ready for Christmas Cookie Baking 2013? Here are some baking tips to get you started:

Freshen up your ingredients. That half-empty bottle of vanilla extract in the pantry? Sure, it’ll make decent cookies. But for real, intense flavor, you’ll want to purchase fresh vanilla (and also peppermint, almond or other extracts you may need for holiday baking). I recently opened a fresh bottle of almond extract and was surprised by the depth of its flavor compared to the old bottle it replaced. I like Penzey’s extracts for quality and taste.

While you’re at it, pick up fresh canisters of baking powder and baking soda; when you get home, use a Sharpie to write the month and year on the lids. These baking essentials lose their leavening power quickly, and it’s recommended that you replace them every six months.

Ditto flour. If you don’t go through it quickly, it might be wise to replace that old bag of all-purpose. Whole-wheat flours especially tend to go “off” with storage of more than 10–12 months, as their oils can get rancid (you can keep whole-grain flours in the freezer to extend their life).

Ditto baking spices. Most spices have a shelf life of 2 years, max. If you’re not sure how long that tin of ground ginger has been lurking in the spice rack, might as well buy fresh. Some groceries like The Fresh Market and independent spice shops will sell small quantities, so you don’t wind up spending on more ground cloves than you need. Fresh spices make a huge difference in flavor, and this is the season when you especially don’t want to skimp.

Plan and shop ahead. Bookmark (online and off-) the recipes you want to make, and create a shopping list that aggregates all the ingredients you’ll need. There’s nothing worse than being an egg short when you’re in the middle of a baking project. Too, consider which of your Christmas cookie recipes can be made ahead and frozen.

Consider packaging. If you’re making cookies as holiday gifts, then look for pretty packaging to wrap them in. has tons of wonderful cookie packaging ideas.

Stay tuned throughout December for my best Christmas cookie recipes, and visit my Christmas Cookie Inspiration Board on Pinterest!

3 thoughts on “Christmas cookie recipes and tips.

  1. Great reminders for the fun that’s about to begin! I,too, go a bit cookie crazy at Christmas, but I also rope my friends into the frenzy. My small kitchen looks like an over-stocked holiday baking aisle, with all ingredients lined up, the respective recipes attached and a large pot of cocoa on the stove to sustain the madness. Love it! Happy baking and happy holidays to you!

  2. Thanks for the comment, Ann! Have fun with your Christmas cookie baking over the next couple of weeks. The weather is so icky, there’s nothing better to do than play with flour and sugar, anyway!

  3. Pingback: Christmas Cookie-Palooza: Hermits. | writes4food